Changing Retirement Plan Rules

President Trump recently signed an executive order to make it easier for small employers to offer 401(k)s through multiple-employer plans and to review the rules on required minimum distributions (RMDs).

Expanding access to multiple employer plans is a good idea and a central component of the Retirement Enhancement and Savings Act of 2018, which is winding its way through Congress.

The recommendation regarding RMDs, however, seemed to come from left field. Left-field proposals mean we have to think about things that are not at the top of our agenda. So the question is whether the rules surrounding RMDs need fixing.

Under current law, holders of 401(k) and traditional Individual Retirement Accounts (IRAs) are required to withdraw a percentage of their account balances each year once they reach 70½. This requirement assures that the money in these tax-favored saving accounts is used to provide income during retirement rather than to pass on wealth to heirs. The RMD is calculated so as to spread balances over the participants’ remaining lives. The penalty for failure to take an RMD is draconian: 50% of the amount that should have been withdrawn.

The intent of the RMD seems sensible to me. The Treasury forgoes tax revenues to encourage retirement saving; the balances in the retirement accounts should be used for this purpose. I don’t want to have to pay higher taxes so rich people can leave bigger estates.

That said, if I were in charge, I would make three changes to the RMDs:

1) Keep the life expectancy tables up to date. My understanding is that the tables were last updated in 2002, which means that people are currently living about one to two years longer than assumed in the calculation and taking out slightly too much money up front. The tables should be updated automatically, say, every five years.

2) Exempt holders of small account balances. The median 401(k)/IRA balance for households with a 401(k) approaching retirement is $135,000. Make a rule that households with total retirement account assets at 70½ less than $250,000 (indexed for inflation) are exempt from the RMD requirements. (Exempting small balances was suggested by Mark Iwry, a former Treasury official, and included in two of President Obama’s budget requests. Such a provision is also part of the current House tax bill).

3) Make the penalty less draconian. A 50% tax penalty is dramatically out of line with other penalties in the retirement account system. Perhaps, reduce it to 10%.

I don’t think the executive order, which is a little hard to decipher, is aimed at these kinds of RMD changes, however. My interpretation is that the president would like to see the age moved from 70½ to, say, 72. That seems unnecessary and undesirable for three reasons.

First, 80% of people are no longer working by 70½ and, therefore, presumably need to tap their balances.

Second, under current law, many older workers are already exempt with respect to balances held at their current employer. That is, I’m over 70½ and don’t have to take RMDs on my Boston College savings.

Third, the presumption is that retirees do not need their 401(k)/IRA balances. In fact, most retired Americans do need these assets to augment their Social Security benefits. Yet, the evidence suggests they are reluctant to tap their nest egg. The RMD provides a nudge in the right direction.

#retirementplanning #Investmentexperts #taxadvice #FinancialPlan #wealthmanagement #portfoliomanagement #registeredinvestmentadvisor #stocksandbonds #financialnews #RequiredMinimumDistributionRetirementplan

26 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All

Privacy Policy. 

Akin Investment never sells your information. All information gathered on this website is for the purpose of helping our clients and nothing is shared or sold to any third party. We value our clients trust and privacy.


This web site contains links to other sites. Please be aware that we are not responsible for the content or privacy practices of such other sites.  We encourage our users to be aware when they leave our site and to read the privacy statements of any other site that collects personally identifiable information. 


External links disclaimer. Throughout our site you will find links to external websites Although we make every effort to ensure these links are accurate, up to date and relevant, Akin Investment Advisory cannot take responsibility for pages maintained by external providers. Â Please note that external links from this website are provided as a courtesy. We take no responsibility for information contained on external links from this website. 


Registration or subscriptions

In order to use certain sections like our “Book online” feature on this website, a user must first complete the registration form.  During registration a user is required to give certain information (such as name and email address). This information is used to contact you about the services on our site in which you have expressed interest.  At your option, you may also provide demographic information (such as gender or age) about yourself, but it is not required. 


This site is intended for clients and interested investors residing in states where Akin Investments, llc is qualified to provide investment services. Akin Investments, llc is a Registered Investment Adviser, located in Biloxi, Mississippi registered with the State of Mississippi. Akin Investments, llc may conduct business in those states or locations in which it is registered or qualifies for an exemption or exclusion from registration requirements similar to or as provided for under established de minimis rules.


Akin Investments, llc website in no event shall the presence of this website on the internet be interpreted or construed as a solicitation to provide investment advisory services outside of the State of Mississippi, South Carolina or outside of those states with an established de minimis rule. If you have questions on your specific situation please reach out to Akin Investments, llc at (601) 974--0549.


Akin Investments, llc does not make any representations or warranties as to the accuracy, timeliness, suitability, completeness, or relevance of any information prepared by any unaffiliated third party, whether linked to Akin Investments, llc. web site or incorporated herein, and takes no responsibility therefor. All such information is provided solely for convenience purposes only and all users thereof should be guided accordingly.


  • LinkedIn Social Icon
  • Facebook Social Icon
  • Twitter Social Icon
  • Pinterest Social Icon
  • Instagram Social Icon


102 North Mill Street, Suite 906 Jackson, Mississippi 39201 


All Rights ©2015-2021 by Akin Investments, LLC. Proudly created with